Bokhandleren i Kabul PDF õ Bokhandleren i MOBI
After finishing the book, I was quite surprised at the number of negative reviews here in Goodreads Maybe a huge culture shock is at play here Many in the West may be put off by the realization that the values that they take for granted may be totally unheard of in certain parts of the world There are certain cultures where children are nothing but tools for parents and as such, are actively denied education There are cultures where falling in love is a greater crime than sawing off a person s head I know for a fact that people in my culture have gotten used to murders and negligence of human rights, but if a couple were caught kissing in public, as it were the very fabric of society would be shred to smithereens There are societies where women are nothing than baby making and house keeping machines, commodities which are to be sold off in the financial ritual of marriage Since I grew up in a culture not vastly different from the one portrayed in this book, I find it hard to dismiss this account as prejudiced hogwash That, and I also steer clear of any sort of cultural relativism I know for a fact that no one in the comparatively progressive world would want to be a woman in Afghan society after reading this book, even so after living in the country for some time by himself herself The author may not have captured Afghan culture in its entirety and no where has she made that claim , but she has been anything but prejudiced.For me, the pathos in this book lies in the hopes and aspirations of the members of the Khan family living in a post Taliban Afghanistan The women want education and a job, the children want to play, young men and women of the country want to fall in love in spite of knowing the dire consequences, and Sultan Khan wants to contribute towards building a better and liberal Afghanistan, a country which he can boast of to the world This book draws a very humane picture of an obscure society, a picture that very often fails to filter through the coloured glasses of mainstream media. Sua Majestade O IslamismoA queda dos Taliban no Afeganist o surtiu alguma abertura no que toca condi o da mulher.As raparigas regressaram s escolas, e mulher foi legalmente concedido, o direito ao trabalho.Contudo, a lei familiar prevalece A fam lia um micro mundo com leis pr prias, e se um pater familiae entender que mais vantajoso vender as filhas h homens abastados no Afeganist o que pagam avultadas quantias para casar com jovens adolescentes para casamento, ou simplesmente us las como escravas dom sticas, adeus escola, adeus carreira, adeus trabalho assim e n o h volta a dar pois um Afeganist o mis gino, que a autora nos apresenta E f lo, socorrendo se duma fam lia criteriosamente escolhida para o efeito a fam lia dum homem culto, um guardi o dos livros e defensor dos direitos das mulheres Este respeit vel patriarca que supostamente teria um perfil progressista, na pr tica revela se um tirano intrag vel, tratando as mulheres como escravas e impedindo os filhos de estudar.Ilustra de forma ex mia o abismo afeg o, que separa uma teoria com alguns laivos de progressismo, duma pr tica tradicionalista milenar e retr grada Embora j com leis a favorec las, as mulheres afeg s continuam com um estatuto muito inferior ao dos homens, a ponto de serem alvo de atos de misoginia criminosa.Entre outros, a autora conta um epis dio chocante em que uma mulher sufocada at morte pelos pr prios irm os, como puni o por se encontrar furtivamente com o amante.Enfim As leis mudam, mas o tradicionalismo cruel e asfixiante sobrep e se Sua Majestade o Islamismo, prossegue inc lume com o seu reinado intemporal O Livreiro de Cabul um romance reportagem escrito por uma correspondente de guerra norueguesa que envergou a burca para melhor narrar a hist ria.Merece um 4 seguido duma copiosa fila de A very interesting, journalistic depiction of life in Afghanistan as told from inside the tent of a relatively well to do family, with particular attention to the experiences of females It is compelling reading, and should be mandatory for anyone who wants to know about life in Afghanistan It is not a good thing to be a female there. Bokhandleren i Kabul The Bookseller of Kabul, sne SeierstadThe Bookseller of Kabul is a non fiction book written by Norwegian journalist sne Seierstad, about a bookseller, Shah Muhammad Rais whose name was changed to Sultan Khan , and his family in Kabul, Afghanistan, published in Norwegian in 2002 and English in 2003 It takes a novelistic approach, focusing on characters and the daily issues that they face 2005 1384 328 21 In spring 2002, following the fall of the Taliban, sne Seierstad spent four months living with a bookseller and his family in Kabul.Forthan twenty years Sultan Khan defied the authorities be they communist or Taliban to supply books to the people of Kabul He was arrested, interrogated and imprisoned by the communists, and watched illiterate Taliban soldiers burn piles of his books in the street He even resorted to hiding most of his stock almost ten thousand books in attics all over Kabul.But while Khan is passionate in his love of books and his hatred of censorship, he also has strict views on family life and the role of women As an outsider, sne Seierstad found herself in a unique position, able to move freely between the private, restricted sphere of the women including Khan s two wives and the freer,public lives of the men.It is an experience that Seierstad finds both fascinating and frustrating As she steps back from the page and allows the Khans to speak for themselves, we learn of proposals and marriages, hope and fear, crime and punishment The result is a genuinely gripping and moving portrait of a family, and a clear eyed assessment of a country struggling to free itself from history to This mesmerizing portrait of a proud man who, through three decades and successive repressive regimes, heroically braved persecution to bring books to the people of Kabul has elicited extraordinary praise throughout the world and become a phenomenal international bestseller The Bookseller of Kabul is startling in its intimacy and its details a revelation of the plight of Afghan women and a window into the surprising realities of daily life in today s Afghanistan. Loved it Not long back from Pakistan and it was the perfect time to read this. Enter the world of the Norwegian journalist, sne Seierstad, who covers the aftermath of the Taliban on society in Afghanistan, and you get what you could expect, but still hope you re wrong a pseudo novelistic attempt at exposing the life of a country in turmoil vicious power struggles chaos.Coming from a liberal Norwegian society, and being a young journalist, it is expected that the book will be written from a pessimistic, typical journalistic point of view In fact, I struggled to get into this novel for nothing in the book presented any characteristics expected of a novel There was no story line at all to begin with No plot, no highs and lows, no lyrical prose, no good or bad, no character building NOTHING But it was a best seller Ya well no fine It was obviously a best seller for reasons beyond my understanding, but as a novel, or well written one nope, sorry The question remains though WHY was it promoted and sold as a novel It is an expanded set of articles dare it be called essays which became long enough to fill up a book It wasn t a story It was a bundle of interviews with all the characters blanketed by a liberal, inexperienced viewpoint from observing filth, poverty, oppression, cruelty, and whatever adjectives or synonyms for it could be found in a journalist s vocabulary Neither the male, nor the female interviewees were good people, according to the interpretation of their family life by the author Bottom line the journalist was disgusted with the whole set up and pushed it down my throat with my consent After all, I wanted to finish the book, right In retrospect I am annoyed with myself for wasting valuable time and energy in allowing it to happen Compared to A Thousand Splendid Suns written by Khaled Hosseini, this was a memoir, an optimistic attempt by a writer to cross the bridge between being an investigative journalist to novelist and just not succeeding very well It is not a type of biography either, and not even remotely on par with a real novelist such as Hosseini, who wrote from within his own community to start off with.But okay, so it wasn t a novel, so let me at least credit the author for her effort It is an in depth look at the typical Afghan family experiencing and surviving different occupations of their country The fact that she stayed three months with Sultan, the book seller, and his extended family, allowed her insight into their lives that is not showered upon many westerners Although she is not present in the book, the situation is presented from her viewpoint It is splashed all over the book Her observations are detailed The book highlights the effect of suppression on human lives In this case, freedom of choice for the men, mostly,was taken away first by the Communists, then Mujahedeen and lastly the Taliban Women never had any freedom neither choice anyway The impact on the people is enormous as far as restructuring their lives is concerned And then 9 11 happened and the Americans came But if I really want to know what is happening now, I will have to consult the internet and the Al Jazeera news channel It will be an extension of this book An investigative journalistic report.I did endure until the last full stop So you wonder how the book ends Well, what do you expect It is always a matter of choice if you want to find out Expectations differ from person to person, after all I will respect your point of view no matter what I apologize for pushing my annoyance down your throat in case you have opted to read to this point Delivering pizzas in Germany is far lucrative than working as a flight engineer in Afghanistan p58 Seierstad, a Norwegian journalist, stayed as a guest of the bookseller of Kabul of the title shortly after the fall of the Taliban view spoiler It is odd really that the USA ended up raining bombs on the Taliban There s a common current between some political persuasions in the USA and the Taliban, both really dislike women having pre martial sex, both are strongly inspired by the Bible and want to see religion at the heart of their national cultures, both believe in saying no to drugs, yet perhaps when it came down to it the Americans were just too jealous of the Taliban s free and easy gun culture But that s the nature of war, to make strange allies and stranger enemies hide spoiler Asne Seirstadt writes an honest and candid account of her four months of life with an Afghan family, following the fall of the Taliban and the end of the reign of terror they subjected the Afghan people to.She spent these months with the family of Sultan Khan who for twenty years defied the tyranny of the Communists and then the Taliban by selling books on the black market because the tyrants did not allow books except those which subscribed to their narrow minded and sick ideas.Afghanistan was a great, progressive and vibrant country during the reign of King Zahir Shah who was overthrown by Mohammed Daoud Khan in 1973 after which followed 5 years of instability and then the sheer hell of Communist repression followed shortly thereafter by the Taliban s reign of terror.During the 70s already under dressed women risked being shot in the legs or having acid sprayed in their faces by the fundamentalists.After the civil war broke out and women had to cover up After the Taliban seized power all female faces disappeared from the streets of Kabul.My heart really hurts for these women and girls who suffered so under the Islamists and had to be hidden away and obey through fear.And I point an accusing finger at all those leftists who claim to believe in feminism but defend excesses Should women in these countries got less rights than what you people take for granted Even after the Taliban were overthrown women and girls feared going out alone or dressing as they pleased, because of the residue of terror that the Taliban had left behind.During the Taliban era one of the most hated buildings in Kabul was the Department for the Promotion of Virtue and Extermination of Sin Here women who had walked unescorted by a male relative, or who wore makeup under their burkas, and men who cut their beards, languished under torture and many died.Before that these had once bee the headquarters of the equally brutal Soviets.No wonder Leftists and Islamo Fascists love each other so much They both have the mania for cruelty and destruction and the death impulse.Asne Seirstadt witnessed the destruction and death left behind by the Taliban.The Taliban engaged in ethnic cleansing of the Tajiks and other minorities in northern Afghanistan, raising entire villages to the ground and poisoning water wells and blowing water pipes and dams vital for survival in these dry plains before they withdrew.Seirstadt masterfully covers the sights, sounds and smells of Afghanistan from the cramped life in people s houses where extended families lived together to the bazaars and the hamman , the massive communal bath, where thousands of women cleaned themselves and their children on certain days of the week.Seirstadt captures much of Afghanistan s history and life and culture in these pages.It is an excellent book for those who want to learn about this country. I think I learned from this one book than from any news story or other examination of Afghanistan You think, after reading the forward and the beginning of the book, that the bookseller will be a progressive man, but his love for his country s history and its literary heritage is his only redeeming quality and yet the very reason he is such a bastard toward his family Everything comes second to his passion In the wake of the Taliban s withdrawal we see them slowly try to regain their freedoms, but after years of outside oppression, the feeling has slowly sunk inward Sultan s sister is too repressed to speak up in her own defense His sons do not speak up against their father s wishes which prevent them from having a decent childhood as they slave away in his shops And his own wife, once a respected professor, must bow to the will of her firstborn who says he does not want to work, even though it is her only desire There are glimmers of hope along the way as fate does give the women, who become the true stars of this book a chance And there are some wiser people amongst the Khan family who have figured out what the country truly needs and that peace is dependent upon throwing off the desire for power that has caused so much war in the country Ironically, at one point in the book, a hotel guard in the worst territory in Afghanistan, observing one of Khan s family members helping an American journalist operate a satellite phone, the likes of which the hotel guard has never seen, says Do you know what our problem is We know everything about our weapons but we know nothing about how to use a telephone Lack of communication seems to be the greatest obstacle in the book and the one that holds the country back Hopefully that will soon change But in the meantime, if you really want to get a glimpse into true Afghan life, buy this book.